Boys and girls in Toyland


We were in the toy aisle around lunch time. The boys were in the stroller, each one holding a stuffed dog, one of which donned a purple bow around its neck. We were searching for a birthday present for a boy and thus surrounded by Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and super heroes and Legos and battery operated vehicles. We were in the company of another mom with two boys and a man who appeared to be alone. I was trying to decide which combination of TMNJs to buy when a boy who looked to be about five years old rounded the corner.

“Hey, Dad, can I get this?” he asked.

The man who I thought was alone said, and loudly, “You’re not getting that. That’s a girl toy.”

“But Dad…”

“No way is my son playing with girls toys.”

“But Dad…”

“Put. It. Back.”

The boy surrendered. He walked away, deflated and dejected.

I stood there pretending to be engrossed in the task at hand. I never looked up. I still don’t know what this man looked like. It wasn’t my place to say anything, yet I can’t get that little boy out of my head.

I wonder if that man considered the two women in his company, how his comment outright revealed him to believe our sex “less than”, for we too were once girls playing with “girl toys”. I wonder if he considered the four other little boys in his presence, one of whom held tightly to an accessorized stuffed animal. He certainly didn’t consider his own son, which irritates me most. Not that he didn’t acknowledge a (perhaps extraneous) want, but that he failed to acknowledge what that want revealed about his son.

I never looked up to see what the boy carried in his hands but I can only imagine that it was pink. Maybe it was a doll or a wand or a My Little Pony. Maybe it was something as ambiguous as play food or a stuffed dog with a bow around its neck. Whatever it was, it obviously screamed GIRL and GIRL is obviously not okay with this man, so I wonder: What does GIRL signify? Weakness? Sensitivity? Tenderness? Affection? Inferiority?

girls and swords

Mia plays with water guns and toy bow and arrows. She likes Star Wars and Angry Birds. Of all the toys my mom kept from when my brother and I were little, her favorites include a pirate ship and an old fire engine. At the completion of day camp last summer, I asked what her favorite activity was, expecting her to say crafts or swimming or horseback riding, but much to my surprise it was archery.

My boys will rock a baby doll in their arms as they giggle and groove to Taylor Swift. They find discarded stuffed animals in a closet and smother them with kisses as though they’ve rescued an abandoned baby on someone’s doorstep.

Boys and baby dolls

My children share toys. They trade and take turns and squabble over them. We’ve never tried to impose contrived codes and guidelines, nor do we want to. As long as they’re safe, they’re free to explore and imagine and create. I know we’re not alone in this approach. In fact, we’re probably a part of the majority.

Caring for baby dolls teaches children compassion and empathy. A superhero cape has the power to command invincibility. A wand lets them harness magic. A blank canvas and a set of paints can unlock the vast imaginative realm inside their minds. A book (any book) can provide an escape or a different perspective or a fantastical world to get lost in. This is what we want for our children, part of what we try to instill in them, isn’t it? Compassion and empathy and creativity and the space and freedom to be anything or anyone they want to be.

The world is yours.

The sky is the limit.

You can do anything you set your mind to.


Pink is for girls.

Boys don’t cry.

Be tough. Shake it off.

Girls can be mild and boys can be wild, and we accept this as a general rule. Let us also accept that girls can be mighty and tenacious and boys can be merciful and tender — in play and in life.

So let me ask: If we don’t ever teach them that pink is for girls and blue is for boys, would they come to this conclusion on their own? If we don’t push fairy wands into the hands of girls and swords into the hands of boys, would they still gravitate to what society has deemed gender appropriate? Do we realize that when we dismiss the wants and interests of our kids, we are also dismissing hidden potential, inhibiting imaginative play and hindering creativity?

boys and cupcakes

Did that little boy in the toy aisle leave with the conclusion that he is “less than” for coveting a “girl toy”? Did his father implant a seed that will burrow into his psyche and help shape the way he sees the world and girls? His emotions? Himself?

It was only an errand. It was only a comment that wasn’t directed at me by a man I don’t know. And yet I can’t shake the feeling that I was witness to a pivotal moment on the path of this little boy’s life.


5 thoughts on “Boys and girls in Toyland

  1. Cecilia says:

    Wonderful post. Those kinds of stories make me incredibly sad. I remember chatting with a dad once while watching our boys in their martial arts class. This dad would shout instructions at his son and shake his head in exasperation whenever his son failed to do a kick or some other movement “right.” When I asked him how his son liked the sport, he said, “He hates it. He only likes girl things like reading and drawing.” I said to him, “That’s okay. That’s great that he likes reading and drawing.” but there was so much disgust in his voice. I didn’t know the dad, and only saw him a few times in the classes so I also didn’t feel it was my place to tell him what to do.

    We talk a lot about the importance of nurturing our girls’ self esteem (and for good reason), but we (as a society) often neglect to do the same for our boys. We’re under the false notion that boys are confident and powerful and privileged in the amounts of confidence and power that they have, when maybe the reason some of them are so aggressive is because they lack self esteem. I remember always being so glad I was born a girl, because then it would be okay to cry and to show weakness and to be myself.

  2. Alicia says:

    I recently painted my nails for the first time in a long time and my son wanted his nails painted too. They were red, his favorite color, after all. At first I told him that nail polish is usually something only girls use. The next time he asked we were in the car and I said OK with the understanding that it couldnt be right that minute. He hasn’t asked again but I’m wondering if I should paint them for him if he does. He is starting to show his rough and tumble “boy” side more than ever but has always been very in tune with others’ feelings and fairly calm. Painted nails or not, wild or calm, I just love this kid!

    • Alicia says:

      Hah! I just realized that my little guy is wearing a pink life vest in my picture. It wasn’t his choice, but no one (including his dad or our friend who is a father of 2 girls and with us that day) cared at all. Safety (for boating and self esteem) first! 😉

  3. Heidi says:

    I’ve seen things like this happen before, too. And it makes me sad. I’ve tried to encourage my three to choose what they like regardless of assumed gender roles. And to accept others’ choices without labeling them.

  4. now at home mom says:

    It makes me very sad to hear that some men are still behaving this way, I would love to believe that in the future man and woman will no longer be so mean and try to label everything. I feel bad for that little boy too even if I wasn’t there.
    You know, last summer, when we went shopping to IKEA, we saw a man screaming at his boy in front of everyone, I was ashamed for his behaviour and felt so bad for the little boy because I knew that at the end of his day, he’s the one that will feel bad about happened to him in that store; the humiliation from his father.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s